As Wall Street economists up the odds for a recession in the coming year, the bond market is sending its own scary warning about an economic downturn.
The 10-year yield, at its low yield of 1.642% Tuesday came as few as 3 basis points above the 2-year yield, which was at 1.603%. The spread broke below 10 basis points last week. An inverted curve simply means a shorter-term interest rate is higher than the longer-term one that it is being compared too, and that inversion has been a reliable recession signal.
“It’s the whole idea that the Fed is making a mistake. There’s more fear that the Fed is going to be slow in making moves, and the economy is going to to into recession,” said Andrew Brenner, National Alliance head of international fixed income.
The Fed watches the spread between the 3-month bill yield and the 10-year note yield which has been inverted, but the markets traditionally have watched the 10-year and the yield on the 2-year note.
“I don’t know if it matters more than the 3-month to the 10-year, but you can call it the final nail in this whole yield curve inversion discussion,” said Peter Boockvar, chief investment officer at Bleakley Advisory Group.
Economists lately have been more concerned about the chances for a recession. Bank of America Merrill Lynch economists said they see odds for a recession now at a 1-in-3 chance in the next 12 months, and Goldman Sachs economists lowered their forecast for fourth quarter growth to 1.8% and said fears of a recession are growing because of the trade war.
The spread between the 3-month Treasury bill and the 10-year note has been inverted with the 3-month bill yielding about 35 basis points more. The benchmark 10-year note yield has been falling as global interest rates decline in a flight-to-safety play and on worries about economic growth.
Spread between 10-year note yield and 2-year from 2007
The 10-year yield, now near its lowest level since October, 2016, influences lending rates for mortgages and other business and consumer loans. Strategists say the curve has to remain inverted for some time to reliably signal recession.
“People express their shorter-term market opinions in the 10-years or less. The next question is how long does it stay that way,” said Boockvar. “I still think the rest of the curve is saying a lot, and it stayed inverted for more than a month.”
Jon Hill, BMO rate strategist at BMO, said in reality the curve should be getting further apart, not closer.
“It’s an interesting moment from a fundamental perspective. Steeper makes sense but the flight to quality we’ve seen and falling inflation compensation has really pushed back against that,” said Hill.
The yield curve flattened after Tuesday’s report of core CPI was slightly higher than expected, up 0.3% versus expectations of 0.2%. The short end of the curve responded, with the 2-year yield rising and the 10-year holding steady.
“I think it’s yet another recession signal … and I don’t know which one is scariest,” said Hill of the flattening spread. He said the fact the yield curve is flattening after the Fed cut interest rates is a negative sign.
“It’s complicated by the ratcheting up in trade tensions, but right now it seems that the current stance of monetary policy is insufficiently accommodative,” he said.