Although they were seemingly a lowkey couple, Carrie Underwood had some dirt to spill about her time with Tony Romo. After reportedly splitting in 2007, she later released a song called “Cowboy Casanova” in 2009 and many assumed she wrote the song for the celeb QB. But she told Esquire that she did nothing of the sort. The former American Idol judge said at the time, “I would never immortalize a guy that did me wrong. I would never give him that much credit.” Does that sound like a lot more went down than just him being “about football” and only football, right?
In any case, both stars have since moved on. Underwood married NHL player Mike Fisher in 2010. They have two children together and starred in a docu-series about their relationship, Mike and Carrie: God & Country, per Women’s Health. Meanwhile, Romo married Candice Crawford in 2011 and they have three kids together, so everything ended up for the best, wrongdoings aside.