Joe Raedle/Getty Images
Look at his ratings on polling aggregators like RealClearPolitics or FiveThirtyEight, and the drop sure looks dramatic.
While his approval rating has fallen and that gap between approval and disapproval has widened considerably, it has not shifted in any extraordinary sense. This is, in part, because of how those charts are scaled, as well as the fact that they show the widening gap between approval and disapproval (and that he started lower than past presidents — there’s only so far you can go).
To be clear, this isn’t to say that those are misleading. But it is to say that with more historical context, Trump’s sliding approval rating really hasn’t slid that much.
By RealClearPolitics’ average, Trump’s approval rating has fallen off by around 4 points since the first day of his term. FiveThirtyEight has it a bit bigger, at around 6 points. We wanted to know how big this type of decline compared to other presidents. Gallup has been tracking presidential approval ratings since the Truman administration, so we used their data to figure this out.
According to Gallup, Trump’s approval rating is 5 points lower than it was when he took office. Compared to that, other presidents’ approval ratings in their first four months have fallen by more — often, much more — than that once they took office. (Gallup measured approval ratings less often in the past, so we tried to find approximate time periods for other presidents.)
Trump’s disapproval rating has also climbed, by 9 points in Gallup’s poll. Once again, this is far smaller than the increase that most other presidents have sustained in their first four months.
As a side note here, you might notice that Trump’s disapproval increase is larger than the decline in his approval rating, which may seem odd, but that’s a common trend among presidents.
When pollsters have asked in late January about approval of new presidents, people often answer that they don’t know how they feel or have no opinion; people simply haven’t known that president long enough. So once they do decide, approval and disapproval ratings both tend to climb. (For Trump, check out the Jan. 31 through Feb. 3 period, which shows a sharp climb in both). During that sorting out, as it turns out, disapproval often climbs by more than approval.
“[Approval] is a pretty labile measure in general,” said Frank Newport, editor-in-chief at Gallup. But for Trump, he said, it just “isn’t changing much.”
He added, “When I talk about it, I generally say his approval hasn’t changed that much on a relative basis.”
A big part of this is, of course, that his approval is so low that it doesn’t have as much room to fall as it otherwise might. From that perspective, it could be considered notable that his approval rating has fallen as much as other presidents whose approval ratings were much higher.
As with so many other phenomena in politics these days, polarization appears to be another driving factor here.
Democrats had little love for Trump to begin with, and nothing thus far has shaken Republicans’ loyalty to him. Given his record-low approval ratings, Trump would have to lose ground among independents and Republicans in order to dip much more.
For proof, a look at the smallest gap between Republicans’ and Democrats’ views of the past dozen presidents during their first (roughly) four months in office.
Granted, there are differences between Gallup’s data in the 1960s and today — that is, they took far fewer measurements of approval than they do now, so it doesn’t have the day-to-day ups and downs that today might make any given gap slightly smaller or bigger.
But the trend is what’s important — approval gaps for new presidents have widened in recent years, and for Trump, the gap is remarkably wide.
One telling historical comparison of how polarizing Trump in particular is: Democrats’ approval of the president is at 8 percent right now, according to Gallup. That’s right around, or perhaps even a hair under, where Democrats’ approval of Nixon was when he left office.
“It’s more tribal than anything else,” said Patrick Murray, founding director of the Monmouth University Polling Institute. “The two-party system has moved from this idea that these were two admirable foes who just have different approaches to governance to seeing the other party as an existential threat.”
He points to the relative movement (or lack thereof) of approval by party as proof.
He points to the fact that Nixon’s job approval fell to the mid-20s by the end of his presidency, when he was embroiled in the Watergate scandal.
Should the Russia investigation become much more damaging to the White House or should another scandal arise, Murray said, “there’s the possibility that that won’t happen to Donald Trump, because people are so viscerally tied to their party identification today.”